imsocute3658 Says:

Jul 27, 2008 - she sounds good til it gets 2 da end then she starts cracking.but i liked it.plus all she needed was a few voice lessons

Beibene Says:

Jul 27, 2008 - She was only 15 ;)

calico102c Says:

Jul 29, 2008 - The ending was horrible!!! but in her defense, she was only 15, probably didnt know how to pace herself etc. there is def talent there, it just needed to be molded....

LauraLauraLauraxsx Says:

Aug 3, 2008 - aww bless her she sounds cute lolshes amazin now.

JanaMusic94 Says:

Aug 5, 2008 - She is good!

Num1bfan Says:

Aug 5, 2008 - I know 15 year old that can sing they ass off... so age dont matter... look at Jamia nash she is 11 and has one of the best voices out here for a child.. Look at Karina Pasian she is 17 and she can BLOW...and Alexis jordan.... this chick can sing so good.... so age does not matter SORRY! :(

lildanial555 Says:

Aug 10, 2008 - At the end she strained her throat trying to hit that note.

chibitotoro1 Says:

Aug 15, 2008 - I can sense her nervousness. But her riffs are quite good, for no training (I think she didn't have any training) She made it her own. She was very shakey, and that caused her to get off key. She was SO nervous :(But she tried, and good fo her!

pimppi3987 Says:

Aug 19, 2008 - she sounded good in the beginning. at the ending, she should have sung the higher notes in the head register.

lioninthelunch Says:

Aug 24, 2008 - Terrible...Rihanna can't sing to save her bajan ass!She just gets worst as the video goes on.Nervous?How is it that she gets nervous towards the ending of the song... heffah just can't sing.@ 2:55 she sound like she was choking on jerk chicken. Her momma know she bad because she didn't clap for her. I didn't her say" that's my baby" or go girl" or anything while recording! her and Chris brown can eat a bag of Meow Mix while singing a duet together cuz they sound like alley cats! just my opinion

abcilovesyz Says:

Aug 28, 2008 - is that sarcasm?

krazyeddyfreak Says:

Aug 29, 2008 - SHE SUCKS!-all i have to say

GermanMimiFan Says:

Aug 29, 2008 - It was horrible!!!

nairamdal2 Says:

Aug 29, 2008 - i think she has a very different voice than other singers and i like that.... but she has chosen a wrong song for her voice! i thought it was a bit horrible at the end!

RihannaROX4evr Says:

Aug 29, 2008 - actually rihanna was 15 there, not 17 retard.and she doesn't sing bad here just a few notes were hit off that's all. because she still hasn't gotten experience in singing before the talent show. so cut her sum slack. ok? i bet ur not even as good as her here. ha ha.

iezze00 Says:

Aug 30, 2008 - I Like Rihanna she is the best of all singers!!!! Your Sucks

d4balla Says:

Aug 31, 2008 - man she so good.. and cute as hell man

Ekinacea Says:

Sep 1, 2008 - Horrible!!! and it hasn't to do with her age 'cause aguilera sang amanzingly when she was even younger! It's a matter about having voice abilities or not and rihanna hasn't!!! She must sing her songs, not mariah's ones!

emmasmithhh Says:

Sep 1, 2008 - she's not a bad singer, but i think its stupid audience goes crazy over things that aren't that hard =/ ( :25 )

emmasmithhh Says:

Sep 1, 2008 - um, nvm. the end was a trainwreck =/

CatocaIaLacrymosa Says:

Sep 2, 2008 - I have to puke

obbzerver Says:

Sep 2, 2008 - She's just another generic singer who got made into a star. She uses the same annoying "urban melisma" arpeggiation/warble they do on virtually every long vowel that every black pop singer in America uses and that now every white singer is annoyingly imitating.This is probably what her studio performances sound like before they've been processed and pitch corrected.

hahaha7121 Says:

Sep 2, 2008 - ew!! lmao!! the end!! omg wtf lmfao!!

Falhozbazdoslak1 Says:

Sep 3, 2008 - If I was there I slap her face=)=)=)=)=)=)=)

danielonethebest Says:

Sep 3, 2008 - the worst thing I ever seen, mariah carey is 1000 steps on rihanna